Week 8.1: Depression-Era Photographs

Margaret Bourke-White (1904-71) was a pioneering figure in 20th century documentary photography and is famous for her scenes of modern industry, of the Great Depression, and of political and social movements in the 1920s through 1950s. Born in New York in 1904, Bourke-White attended Columbia University to study under renowned photographer, Clarence White. In 1927 she moved to Cleveland, the heartland of American industry, and opened her own studio. There she documented the effects of modern industry on the land and people.  In 1929, Bourke-White became the first staff photographer employed by Fortune magazine. In keeping with her groundbreaking work in the United States, Bourke-White obtained permission in 1930 to enter the Soviet Union to document industrialization under the Communist regime. Upon her return in 1931, she compiled these photographs into a book entitled Eyes of Russia. When Bourke-White returned to the United States she developed a greater sympathy for the suffering of the American worker. By 1935 she was using a more candid style of photography, sequentially ordering her photographs to create visual narratives. Bourke-White started using this new approach in photography for Fortune Magazine in 1934 as she set off to document the effects of the intense drought of the Dust Bowl in Oklahoma and other Great Plains states. She created a photographic essay of the migration from this region at the height of the Great Depression and in 1936 published these images in a volume entitled You Have Seen Their Faces. (bio from The Philips Collection)


Dorothea Lange (1895-65) was an American photographer.  From 1917 to 1918 she attended a photography course run by Clarence H. White at Columbia University, NY. Lange moved to San Francisco in 1918, and in 1919 she set up a successful portrait studio where she took works such as Clayburgh Children, San Francisco (1924; Oakland, CA, Mus.). In the late 1920s she became dissatisfied with studio work and experimented with landscape and plant photography, although she found the results unsatisfactory. With the Stock Market crash of 1929 Lange decided to look for subjects outside her studio. Turning to the effects of the economic decline she took photographs such as General Strike, San Francisco (1934; Oakland, CA, Mus.). She had her first one-woman show at the Brockhurst Studio of Willard Van Dyke in Oakland, CA (1934), and in the same year met the economist Paul Schuster Taylor, under whom she worked for the California State Emergency Relief Administration in 1935. Later that year she transferred to the Resettlement Administration, set up to deal with the problem of the migration of agricultural workers. She continued to work for this body, through its various transformations (including its time as the Farm Security Administration), until 1942. One of her most famous photographs from this project is Migrant Mother, Nipomo, California (1936; Washington, DC, Lib. Congr.), which depicts an anxious, distracted mother and three children. In 1939, in collaboration with Taylor, who provided the text, she published An American Exodus, which dealt with the same social problems.  (from her MOMA biography)

Walker Evans (1903-75) began to photograph in the late 1920s, making snapshots during a European trip. Upon his return to New York, he published his first images in 1930. During the Great Depression, Evans began to photograph for the Resettlement Administration, later known as the Farm Security Administration (FSA), documenting workers and architecture in the Southeastern states. In 1936 he traveled with the writer James Agee to illustrate an article on tenant farm families for Fortune magazine; the book Let Us Now Praise Famous Men came out of this collaboration.Throughout his career Evans contributed photographs to numerous publications, including three devoted solely to his work. In 1965 he left Fortune, where he had been a staff photographer for twenty years, to become a professor of photography and graphic design at Yale University. He remained in the position until 1974, a year before his death. (bio from Andrea Rosen Gallery)


 Photographs by Margaret Bourke-White

Margaret Bourke-White, Bernice Daunora, 31, a member of a steel mill's 'top gang' must wear a 'one-hour,lightweight breathing apparatus' as protection against gas escaping from blast furnaces, Gary, Ind., 1943.
Margaret Bourke-White, Theresa Arana, 21, takes down temperature recordings at draw furnaces, Gary, Ind., 1943.

Margaret Bourke-White, During the Great Ohio River Flood of 1937, men and women in Louisville, Kentucky, line up seeking food and clothing from a relief station, in front of a billboard proclaiming, 'World's Highest Standard of Living.'

Photographs by Dorothea Lange

Dorothea Lange, Migrant Mother, Nipomo, California (1936)

Dorothea Lange, Woman of the High Plains, Texas Panhandle (1938)

Dorothea Lange, Kern County, California (1938)
Photographs by Walker Evans
 
Walker Evans, Sharecropper's Family, Hale County Alabama (1936)

Walker Evans, Floyd Burroughs' Work Shoes (1936)
Walker Evans, A Child's Grave (1936)


Study Questions:
Begin by looking carefully at all the photographs from the day. Allow yourself to really look at them carefully without rushing through them. When studying these images consider the following:
  • What are you looking at?
  • How are the images composed? How are the objects in the image arranged both in relation to each other and to the frame of the photograph?
  • Where is the camera placed in relationship to the subject of the photograph? What relationship does this produce between the viewer and the subject?
  • How do the photographers use light and shadow to create texture and meaning in the image? 
  • How does the title of the piece inform what you see in the image?
1. The Bourke-White photographs are a study in contrasts. What contrasts can you find between the two female steel mill workers? How do contrasts inform the World's Highest Standard of Living?

2. What is the relationship of the viewer to the subjects in the Dorothea Lange images? How are they similar, how are they different? As for the the Kern County, California image what is the relationship between text and image? What visual pun is Lange making?

3. Two of the Evans photographs presented here are of objects. What are viewers meant to infer from these objects? What sort of access does it offer us to the owners of these objects? How is this different than the image of the sharecropper family?


PAPER 1 DUE